If the Block Pulls Back Equally, Why Does the Block Move but the Man Doesn't?

If action and reaction forces are equal, why does the block move but the man doesn't?

In short: Newton's third law relates the forces two different bodies exert on each other, and by itself it tells you nothing about how either body moves. Motion follows from Newton's second law and the forces acting on each body. The block slides if the man's pull is greater than the floor's friction on the block, and the man stays still because the net force on him is zero.

Three common doubts

1. What is the difference between Newton's second and third laws? Newton's second law uses only the forces acting on one given body, and their sum determines its acceleration. Newton's third law relates the forces that two different bodies exert on each other.

2. When does the block start to slide? When the force the man exerts through the rope is greater than the friction force the floor exerts on the block.

3. Why doesn't the man move? The net force on him is zero. His non-skid soles do not slip, so the friction from the floor is strong enough to balance the pull of the rope on him.

Want more AP Physics 1 help like this?


Equations & Traps: the AP Physics 1 equation deck. See Equations & Traps

AP Physics 1 Mind Maps: every topic on one page. See the Mind Maps

Complete and Continue