Momentum vs. Kinetic Energy: Which Ball is Easier to Catch?

Which ball is easier to catch when both have the same momentum?

In short: A 0.1 kg ball at 20 m/s and a 0.5 kg ball at 4 m/s have the same momentum, 2 kg·m/s, but different kinetic energies: 20 J for the light, fast ball and 4 J for the heavy, slow one. Stopping the light ball takes 5 times more work, so your hand is pushed back 5 times as far.

Three common doubts

1. Both balls have the same momentum, so isn't the effort the same? The momentum is the same, 2 kg·m/s, but the effort of stopping a ball depends on the work needed, which is set by its kinetic energy.

2. How much more work does the light ball need? Its kinetic energy is 20 J compared with 4 J, so stopping it takes 5 times more work.

3. What does that mean for my hand? With a 20 N stopping force, W = Fd gives d = 1 m for the light ball and 0.2 m for the heavy one, so your hand is pushed back 5 times as far for the light ball.

Want more AP Physics 1 help like this?


Equations & Traps: the AP Physics 1 equation deck. See Equations & Traps

AP Physics 1 Mind Maps: every topic on one page. See the Mind Maps

Complete and Continue  
Discussion

0 comments