Why Does the Same Force Give the Heavier Iceboat More Momentum?

Why does the heavier iceboat finish with more momentum under the same force?

In short: The boat of mass 2m finishes with more momentum. Since J = FΔt equals the final momentum, and the heavier boat needs more time to cover the same distance s, the same force acts on it for longer. Both boats finish with the same kinetic energy but with different momentum.

Three common doubts

1. What do "same force" and "same distance" tell me? Both boats start from rest and are pushed by the same force F over the same distance s, so each boat's impulse is J = FΔt, which equals its final momentum.

2. Why is Δt larger for the heavier boat? Its acceleration is smaller, so it takes a longer time to travel the distance s. The same force therefore acts on it for longer.

3. How can the boats have equal kinetic energy but unequal momentum? Kinetic energy is set by the work, F × s, which is the same for both. Momentum is set by the impulse, FΔt, and the heavier boat takes longer, so it ends with more momentum.

Want more AP Physics 1 help like this?


Equations & Traps: the AP Physics 1 equation deck. See Equations & Traps

AP Physics 1 Mind Maps: every topic on one page. See the Mind Maps

Complete and Continue  
Discussion

0 comments