Why Does Pulling Your Hand Back Make a Catch Hurt Less?

Why does pulling your hand back when you catch a ball make it hurt less?

In short: The ball arrives with the same kinetic energy either way, about 7 J, and your hand must remove all of it. By the work-energy theorem, force times stopping distance equals that kinetic energy. Stopping in about 2.5 cm takes almost 300 N, but letting your hand travel 25 cm cuts the force ten times.

Three common doubts

1. Does the ball have less energy when I pull my hand back? No. It arrives with the same kinetic energy either way, about 7 J, fixed the moment the ball leaves the thrower.

2. How does the work-energy theorem give the force? Your hand pushes against the ball's motion, so it does negative work, force times distance, equal to the change in kinetic energy that takes the ball to 0. So force times stopping distance equals the kinetic energy the ball brought in.

3. Why does a longer stopping distance feel softer? A short distance means a big force and a long distance means a small force. By Newton's third law, that smaller force is what your palm feels.

Want more AP Physics 1 help like this?


Equations & Traps: the AP Physics 1 equation deck. See Equations & Traps

AP Physics 1 Mind Maps: every topic on one page. See the Mind Maps

Complete and Continue  
Discussion

0 comments